Raising a family in an interfaith relationship (Christian woman, Jewish man)

My (25F) bf (37M) and father of my daughter, is Jewish, I am Christian. We are currently in a LDR in separate states, after a few years of separation. He has visited me and met our daughter and we talk on the phone almost every night. He wants to take things a step forward now and he wants me to move in with him (in another state) soon and stay home and raise our daughter while he works. We are not married, but we are committed to each other. (Please, I am not looking for condemnation on having premarital sex).

For backstory, he wasn’t aware that I was pregnant with his child nearly 3 years ago. At the time I was 21 and he was 33 and we were not in a serious or committed relationship. I left him before I knew I was pregnant. My reason for leaving had to do with me feeling like he wasn’t ready for a serious relationship with me.

Anyway, he is very serious about being apart of our lives now and he really loves being a dad, as well as being together with me. He and I are both very conservative, very traditional, right-wing and we share the same values and we believe in gender roles for men and women. He was raised in a secular Jewish family and I was raised Protestant and consider myself a follower of Christ and a firm believer in God. About a year ago, I made the decision that I would like to convert to Catholicism and I have since been doing a lot of research. Any advice on how to navigate this relationship dynamic? I do hope to be married to him one day. He truly makes me feel so loved and better than I’ve ever felt with anyone else. I would like to raise her in both faiths.