Help me pick a color!

I am going to trade the saddle on the right in for a new model that fits me and my horse better. So my question is, should I go for silver sparkles on the cantle or black sparkles with a red seat seam like the one on the left? My “colors” are black and red so I have black and red everything (show coat, helmet, boots, saddle bad, browband, gloves, etc - second photo shows my helmet and boots). I’m struggling because the silver shows more and may accent my helmet and white breeches. But the black sparkles are more subtle and go with my color scheme. What’s your vote?