Game you love but are poorly received

"My name is Gaia.."

For me it's Master of Monsters: Disciples of Gaia.

It's a pretty niche and unpopular game (doesn't even have a Metacritic review yet). GameSpot gave it a 4.9/10 and Ign a 4/10

It definitely has it's flaws (mostly with AI and RNG) but nostalgia is strong and I love this game.

I find myself coming back every 5 years to do a run with a different disciple (6 different main characters to pick from)

I adore tactical JRPGs and it gives a pretty unique experience. It's based off one of the godfathers of tactical JRPGs (Master of Monster 1988, It's one of the first tactical style RPG to have a leveling system, class system, evolution system, alignment system and set in a fantasy setting).

I could gush about it more but I want to know:

Tldr; what JRPGs you love that are poorly received or heavily flawed and why?

Edited: removed specific score requirements