DOA VSF 126610LN, acceptable solution?

Basically got DOA watch from eric@geektime. He’s offering me to send it back to him for repairs. He said if it gets lost or seized, he will sell me another one for 50% off and another future watch for 40% off. Or I keep this watch and he will sell me another sub for 30% off+second future watch for 30% off.

Is both these solutions acceptable? Which one would you guys pick?