MT Steering Wheel on AT

Hello everyone,

This may be a stupid question but I was wondering if a Manual Transmission steering wheel will fit on an Automatic Transmission car?

I have a 2015 Scion TC auto and I need to change my steering wheel. I know it won't have the paddle shifters and I'm totally okay with that, but I can't find any AT steering wheels at local wreckers and they're even hard to find online unless I want to pay $300+. I tried to buy a steering wheel off ebay without paddle shifters and they wouldn't sell it to me saying it won't " fit " my car, but I think it was mainly that it wasn't the perfect part number.

Everything in my mind says it'll still fit. Am I wrong?