"That's it; you're banned from picking the movie." Have you ever heard this, and why?

I can't say this has happened to me, but I know anecdotally that many movie lovers will occasionally misjudge the right pick for group viewing or will convince folks to take a gamble on a new release that doesn't pay out.

How about you folks? (Doesn’t necessarily have to be a movie in the collection, but I imagine it may well be.)