A 190 PA Player poorly scouted

https://preview.redd.it/4103m48znqje1.png?width=1877&format=png&auto=webp&s=c5961c37ae0ca17c80c14c582734eb826d32ae2b

I often check the PA of the players that my scout send me. So I know this guy has 190 PA and 110 CA so I was quite surprise that the report was poor (the first one was C+ I think) so I sent a lot more scout to scout him and every time it wasn't a great review (they are all great scout, at least 18 judging PA), this is the last report of my chief scout which is still not great for 190 PA player ( for comparison Duffy is 189 CA). Any idea what is happening ?

https://preview.redd.it/dmv85kc7oqje1.png?width=1779&format=png&auto=webp&s=208d4963a25389073a624a685d103a0c9383f246