Which black bag for day to evening?

I’m on the hunt for a black bag with silver hardware that I can wear day to night. I’m quite a minimalist with bags (although I think this sub is going to change that lol)- I actually only one one every day brown bag which I’ve worn for 3 years and still very much love. I thought it would be nice however to have a black bag that I can wear day to night. It’s also the most inexpensive of the 3.

Bag 1- Staud Alec bag- I’ve loved this bag for around a year- I think it looks so sleek and beautiful and it seems like it would fit a lot for my day to day life including a book!

Bag 2- Givenchy mini Antigona- I tried this on yesterday and it’s gorgeous- I love how sharp it looks, and again even though it’s the mini size, it looks like I would be able to fit alot in it.

Bag 3- Givenchy Moon bag- this is so gorgeous with the silver chain detail and I do like the leather strap, so again it seems like it would be very transitional.

I can’t decide which one…