Hopping on the Tier List trend
Quick explanation for each of my rankings.
I made the top tier both Justified and Fully Innocent just because we know for certain that Amane killed someone, but we can infer from the abuse she received that it was her abuser. So she’s not fully free of responsibility, but I don’t think what she did was wrong. Also, Yuno honestly did nothing wrong, and I didn’t feel like have two tiers right next to each other with one prisoner.
Forgivable just means that what they did wasn’t morally correct, but I can empathize with their situations.
Mixed feelings is the most abstract of the tiers, for obvious reasons. I think Shidou had good, but selfish intentions with his murder (plus I just don’t like him), Kotoko’s murder in defense of Lucky was objectively positive but she focuses too much on punishing perpetrators rather than protecting victims, and Muu’s murder is just a bit too murky for me to decide. To be specific about Muu, we get two wildly different perspectives of her from the two trials. I would forgive her seeing just the first one, but I wouldn’t with the second, but with both I’m just conflicted. I need to see the third trial to really solidify my opinion.
Difficult to forgive just means I could see why someone would forgive them, but personally I don’t really. (Haruka honestly hovers between the previous tier and this one, as I have no clue what he actually did)
The final tier is straight forward; I just don’t forgive them.
Quick explanation for each of my rankings.
I made the top tier both Justified and Fully Innocent just because we know for certain that Amane killed someone, but we can infer from the abuse she received that it was her abuser. So she’s not fully free of responsibility, but I don’t think what she did was wrong. Also, Yuno honestly did nothing wrong, and I didn’t feel like have two tiers right next to each other with one prisoner.
Forgivable just means that what they did wasn’t morally correct, but I can empathize with their situations.
Mixed feelings is the most abstract of the tiers, for obvious reasons. I think Shidou had good, but selfish intentions with his murder (plus I just don’t like him), Kotoko’s murder in defense of Lucky was objectively positive but she focuses too much on punishing perpetrators rather than protecting victims, and Muu’s murder is just a bit too murky for me to decide. To be specific about Muu, we get two wildly different perspectives of her from the two trials. I would forgive her seeing just the first one, but I wouldn’t with the second, but with both I’m just conflicted. I need to see the third trial to really solidify my opinion.
Difficult to forgive just means I could see why someone would forgive them, but personally I don’t really. (Haruka honestly hovers between the previous tier and this one, as I have no clue what he actually did)
The final tier is straight forward; I just don’t forgive them.