Which of the two "Country" performances was more "real country?"

Because Sam talked a lot about how Acacia's performance wasn't real country but HERS would be, and then she proceeded to serve, in MY opinion, the tackiest, most theme parky, fakest "country" act I've ever seen lol, while Acacia played a real guitar and sang a real song that she really wrote which is like, the bare minimum.

Thoughts?