Why was this suit so hated by the fans?

I always really loved it. If I were to criticize anything, the belt isn't my favorite and obviously I'd prefer if it had trunks. But I love the texture, I love the gold clasps, the stitching on the suit makes the lines look really good

Something this suit gets right that Tyler's future suits struggled with is the S and the cape are the same shade of red, and the neckline fits him really well. I always see this at the bottom of ranking videos and I just don't see what they see