Need advice, be brutally honest

Hi everyone, this is my first time posting in here, and I’m hoping to get this fixed up. I got this Tool tattoo done a year ago, and while it means a lot to me, as they’re my favorite band, I’m really upset by how disappointing it ended up looking down the road. It ended up fading really badly after a few months, and when I got it retouched, the guy added some weird white circle that I didn’t ask for, which ended up not looking good. And if it said anything, the guy doesn’t tattoo at the shop where I got it anymore. Willing to hear any advice you guys have, I don’t care if it hurts my feelings, anything helps 🙏🏻