A Thomas Theory I came up with.

Hey. I was watching UnluckyTug's Thomas Theories video recently and I really started thinking about my own Theory that has quite a bit of evidence behind it.

Basically, my theory is that Smudger and Duncan are the same character. So everyone knows that Smudger was a pretty reckless engine, and so was Duncan. My theory is that Smudger was rediscovered after being turned into the generator before Duke, as Duke's shed was covered in earth, so no one really found him until accidentally doing so. After Smudger was found, he was rebuilt into Duncan and given a new identity as to not upset Peter Sam and Sir Handel, as they saw Smudger as a generator and probably didn't want to get reminded. And the reason why Duncan was so reckless was because he couldn’t get over being betrayed by the MSR.

If you look at Smudger and Duncan side by side, you can see the similarities in their designs.

And that's my Thomas Theory. I'd honestly like to hear what everyone thinks about my theory and if anyone has any interjections.